I haven't been active long enough on this website to have something relevant to contribute upon the value of references, but I find the debate quite interesting.

For the time being I will continue reviewing the girls I meet, especially if the experience holds something of notice. I'm not sure what the use of a negative review can be to the community though.

Marco

@oldstallion: don't you find it annoying when people post about who you go see and when?

"... I'm not sure what the use of a negative review can be to the community though..." Plenty!!!
A honest negative review will save many punters money. Not reporting those is a huge disfavor to us.
Let's say you see this girl that you like, then go to her only to find out she was crap, wouldn't it been nice if there was a warning on this site?? Nou toe.

I think we should stop being selfless by not reviewing girls we see. We should be sharing the info. This will surely help us to make better choices of the girls we going to see.
Here is also some suspect reviews that i find. Those reviews sounds like a advert instead of a review.

Marco,
a short review about a lousy appointment will help remove the wheat from the chaff, especially so when she has no reviews yet.
This contrary, Homeboy, to adding anything to a long good list, even if it was a bit under par.
Worse even, I don't read any umpteenth' reviews anymore, hardly news hence boring info. But a first review I will take note of, and I'm sure I'm not alone in this.